Skip to main content
Coaching TipsJuly 2, 20266 min read

How to Run Lacrosse Tryouts: A Fair, Simple Evaluation Plan

Tryouts are uncomfortable for everyone — including the coach. You have two or three hours to sort through a group of players and make decisions that affect their season. Done well, the process is fair, defensible, and relatively stress-free. Done poorly, you end up second-guessing every cut and fielding angry parent calls in February.

This guide gives you a two-session tryout structure you can use at the high school or club level, the drills that actually separate players (not the ones that just look impressive), a simple scoring rubric, and a few things experienced coaches stop doing once they have enough tryouts behind them.

Why Two Sessions Beat One

A single tryout day introduces too much noise. Players who are nervous, late to arrive, or coming off a school game that afternoon look worse than they are. A second session corrects for that. You see who bounces back, who performs under fatigue, and who shows up with the same energy both days.

More practically, two sessions give you a chance to see players in different contexts — individual skill work on day one, competitive small-sided play on day two. Some players look great in drills and disappear in games. Others look rough in lines but are instinctive and competitive when the ball is live. You need both data points.

Session One: Individual Skill and Movement

Keep day one focused and efficient. You are not running a practice — you are collecting information. Move players through stations quickly, keep lines short, and resist the urge to coach. Your job right now is to watch, not teach.

Warm-Up (15 minutes)

Dynamic warm-up with partner passing at close range. Watch how players handle a bad pass — do they adjust their feet and catch it, or do they let it hit the ground? Catching mechanics under minimal pressure is a baseline read you can get for free before you run a single drill.

Ground Ball Station (20 minutes)

Ground balls under pressure reveal more than almost any other drill at tryouts. Run a contested ground ball where two players race to a loose ball simultaneously, then must protect and clear it. You learn hand strength, physicality, instinct, and composure — all in five seconds. Run each player through this multiple times with different matchups.

1v1 Dodging Station (20 minutes)

Set cones at the top of the arc and let attackers go 1v1 to goal against a defender. You are not looking for success rate — you are looking for change of direction, body control, and what a player does when their primary move gets shut down. Does the player reset and try again, or do they force it? That tells you something about competitive instinct.

Passing and Catching Circuit (15 minutes)

Split players into pairs at varying distances — 10 yards, 15 yards, 20 yards. Have them move through progressions: stationary, then on the move, then with a trailing defender adding token pressure. You are checking catch-to-throw quickness and whether the player naturally looks to move the ball or holds it.

Session Two: Competitive Play

Day two should feel like a game, not a tryout. Small-sided play is the most efficient evaluation tool you have because it collapses time and space, forces constant decision-making, and makes it hard to hide.

3v2 Continuous (20 minutes)

Run continuous 3v2s in a half-field set. The offense that scores stays on. The defense that stops the play stays on. Players coming off the bench rotate in as the new third attacker or the fresh defender. The pace is relentless and you get a clear read on who wants the ball in traffic and who fades to the perimeter.

4v4 Small-Sided Scrimmage (30 minutes)

Use a compressed field with small goals or a shortened cage. Four on four puts every player on the ball more often than a full-field scrimmage and eliminates the dead-space problem where a midfielder can jog through a full-field drill without anyone noticing. Keep score. Rotate players every five minutes. Watch how they communicate, how they transition, and how they handle a two-goal deficit.

A Simple Scoring Rubric

You do not need a 20-category spreadsheet. The coaches who agonize most over cuts are usually the ones tracking too many variables. A rubric with four categories is enough to make defensible decisions.

  • •Stick skills (1-5): Can they catch and throw consistently under light pressure? Do they protect the ball?
  • •Athleticism and ground balls (1-5): Quickness, effort, physicality when the ball is loose.
  • •Lacrosse IQ (1-5): Do they understand when to hold and when to move it? Do they fill the right space?
  • •Coachability and effort (1-5): Do they listen? Do they compete hard even in drills they are clearly losing?

Score each player in each category at the end of each session — not in the moment. In-the-moment scoring biases you toward whoever just made the last play. Sit down after tryouts end and score from memory and notes. If you cannot remember a player clearly enough to score them, that is itself a data point.

Common Evaluation Mistakes

  • •Running too many line drills. Lines tell you almost nothing. A player can look sharp in a line drill and be invisible in a game.
  • •Letting reputation carry a player. The kid you coached last summer needs to earn a spot the same way everyone else does. Your rubric protects you here.
  • •Evaluating by position too early. In the first session especially, let players move around. A player who looks average at attack may be a very good midfielder you would have missed.
  • •Ignoring effort and attitude. A player who dogs it during tryouts when they know you are watching will dog it worse once they have made the team.
  • •Making decisions on day one. Wait until you have both sessions scored before you start sorting players into categories.

How to Handle Cuts Respectfully

Cuts are the part of tryouts most coaches dread, and for good reason. How you handle them reflects on your program more than anything else. A few things that make the process cleaner for everyone involved.

Tell players in person whenever possible, or by phone if your numbers are large. A posted list on a gym door or an email blast is a bad look. Keep the conversation short and honest. You do not need to justify every decision, but you should be able to offer one or two specific, actionable things the player can work on before next season. That turns a painful moment into something the player can actually use.

Do not promise a player a spot before tryouts start. Even if you already know you want them. The moment you do that, you have created a situation where the tryout is theater, other players can sense it, and your credibility takes a hit. Let the process be real.

Organize Your Tryout Before It Starts

The coaches who run the smoothest tryouts show up with a written plan — stations mapped out, timing blocked, drills selected. LaxBeacon lets you build a practice plan for each tryout session, time every station, and pull in drill videos gathered from creators across the web so your staff can see exactly what you are running and why. It takes 20 minutes the night before and removes the scrambling on the field.

Build Your Tryout Plan

Free to get started, no credit card required.